Yes, the Twitter redesign is different. No, there are parts of it I don't like either. But yes, it is better for Twitter. Too much is being made of how it's changing too much and it's not the same way it was 5 years ago. People say the same thing about Facebook, and last time I checked, they're doing pretty well.
Twitter is not the same service it was even 2 years ago. Twitter has changed from what was essentially a combination of a text messaging replacement and a group messaging system to a communication platform. It has evolved far beyond what anyone, myself included, thought it could. The recent changes to Twitter make that more evident than ever. Twitter has become more about connecting people and discovering information. It should be no surprise that "connect" and "discover" are two words that feature prominently in the new Twitter design, but more on that later.
As simple of a concept as Twitter is, it actually hit a point where it did become very complicated to use, especially for newer users. The first time you see "RT @wunderbar this #coke commercial is so #winning: bit.ly/1234" (note that is not a real link), how are you supposed to make sense of that? RT, what does that even mean? What is the email sign doing there? why are we putting pound signs in front of random words, and what is this bit.ly thing? It may seem trivial to those of us who have been using Twitter for years, and in some cases literally invented some of those things. (@replies, hashtags, and retweeting were all originally things users did to try to overcome shortcomings of the service that Twitter eventually embraced and built into the service.) Twitter, in all of the simplicity, was becoming complicated. The new design is there specifically to tty to make it simple and more accessible again.
Twitter's new design is focused on 4 things. Home, connect, discover, and Me. Home is pretty self explanatory, that is where your twitter feed is, and where you will spend most of your time. Connect, or @connect as it is branded, combines things like suggested followers, replies, and retweets. this is very akin to the "activity" feed that twitter launched a few months ago. I didn't like the concept of the activity feed before, but after looking at it for a few days now, I can see the value. It is a good tool to see everything that is happening related to you, including who has started following you. the "Me" part is also very simple, that is your profile page. In an unfortunate UI choice that is also where Direct Messages are now found. I *really* dislike that, and hope that they move DM's to somewhere more obvious soon. Having them in the profile page is stupid at best.
Discover, or #discover, is the most interesting part of the redesign. One of the most powerful features of Twitter has always been the ability to search twitter to find out what people are talking about, right now. The power of being able to see what thousands or millions of people are saying at the same time about the same thing cannot be under-estimated. Whether it be during the Egyptian revolution in the spring of 2011, current news events, sporting events, or elections, the ability to do this is something that we have simply never had before. Twitter has been trying to harness this power for a long time. Summize was the first way to search Twitter, and it was so good that Twitter bought it way back in 2008. From there, Twitter introduced Trending Topics, which aimed to show what the most talked about things were on Twitter as they were happening. #Discover is the evolution of that. Discover takes trending topics and evolves them. No longer about providing just the topic itself, but to provide some context. Beside the trending topics will be news stories about them, integrated into the page. It is an interesting new use, and one that I do think will put the idea of the hashtag, trending topics, and search into the forefront of how people use Twitter, as it is much more streamlined.
Twitter also overhauled their apps. Twitter for iPhone, Twitter for Android, and Tweetdeck all received significant updates. Twitter for iPhone and Android have nearly identical UI, and integrate the new features. Now, I've never been a big Twitter for Android user, but I have been forcing myself to use it for the last few days. I can say that I don't hate it, but that I wish it performed faster. It is faster than it was before, but I think I still prefer Tweetdeck for Android. I'm going to keep using Twitter for a while, but I see myself going back to Tweetdeck shortly.
Tweetdeck is another matter. Tweetdeck has always been known as the power users' Twitter. It was powerful and could do more than 95% of users would ever need, and had more customization options than I even knew what to do with. Tweetdeck, like Twitter, was overly complicated, and too complicated for most users to even understand. Twitter bought Tweetdeck recently, and released Tweetdeck 1.0. This has been very controversial, because Tweetdeck has taken some of that power away. Gone are some of the customization options. Gone is some of the features such as Foursquare account support, and most of the Facebook support has been cut. The UI, while similar, has been completely overhauled. Things are now displayed inline instead of in another column or as a focus stealing picture frame, which is consistent with the rest of the Twitter UI. Searching is now easier, and the information is displayed in a way that is easier to see.
That doesn't mean that it is all good. There are many changes to the UI which I frankly hate. How columns are handled now is frankly terrible. instead of a simple horizontal slider to move between columns, especially when you have a number of them, has been replaced with large buttons at either side of the end columns, switching between 2-3 at a time. It is a very unfortunate UI choice which takes away many of the great advantages the column layout has.
some of the options taken away will be missed, and power users will complain that getting to others takes an extra mouse click or two compared to previous versions. Some will dislike that the colour scheme cannot be customized, and some will dislike how it has been "dumbed down" somewhat. Personally, i'm going to miss some of it too, but the changes to Tweetdeck and Twitter are much more positive than they are negative.
When thinking about the changes to Twitter, I've tried to look at it through someone else's eyes. One thing that is easy to forget, especially for power users, is that Twitter is not being made just for us anymore. It is being made so anyone can jump into it and not feel overwhelmed. Twitter is a platform, and a platform has to appeal to everyone. That means making it more accessible, which is what it is now. While it has lost some of the "power" that it had before, I would argue that Twitter now has even more power, because there will be even more people using it, and the real power of Twitter is in the people. If 100 million new people join Twitter after this re-design, which is possible, and even likely, that means that there are 100 million more people to search. I said at the beginning that the real power of twitter is in the ability to find out what people are talking about right now. The more people there are talking about things, the better a metric it is. That is what Twitter wants.
Now, let's not kid ourselves. Twitter is a business, and the real reason for this redesign is advertising. Twitter has been experimenting with promoted items for a long time and this only makes it easier. Brands and companies are easier to promote now, the #Discover page really begs for advertisers to attach their news stories to trending topics, and the @connect page will make it even easier for Twitter to suggest new people and brands for a person to follow. This is a brilliant move by Twitter simply because it will make advertising on the service much more valuable without compromising much of the user experience.
I don't mind the dumbing down of the Twitter service, I don't even mind the prospect of more advertising, as long as the result brings me a better service than it was before. While the changes last week have been very jarring, and change the service more than some people like, overall Twitter is a better service today than it was two weeks ago. The power of Twitter is in the people, and that is evident now more than ever.